Publication Ethics

Ethical Standards and Publication Integrity

International Conference on Economics, Finance and Creative Industries

Commitment to Publication Ethics and Academic Integrity

The International Conference on Economics, Finance and Creative Industries (ICEFCI) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of academic integrity, research transparency, and ethical publication practices.

ICEFCI recognizes that ethical conduct is a shared responsibility among authors, editors, reviewers, and conference organizers. All parties involved in the submission, evaluation, and publication of conference proceedings are expected to uphold principles of honesty, accountability, fairness, confidentiality, and scholarly responsibility.

This policy is informed by internationally recognized publication ethics principles, including the guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Ethical Principles

ICEFCI adopts the following fundamental principles to guide all activities related to scholarly submission, peer review, editorial decisions, and publication:

Academic Honesty All research findings, data, and scholarly contributions must be presented truthfully and accurately.
Originality Submitted manuscripts must represent genuine scholarly contributions and properly acknowledge previous work.
Transparency Authors must disclose relevant research methods, funding sources, conflicts of interest, and ethical considerations.
Fairness and Impartiality Editorial and review decisions must be based on scholarly merit, relevance, and academic quality.
Confidentiality Manuscripts and unpublished research information must be handled responsibly and confidentially.
Accountability All parties are responsible for maintaining the integrity of the scholarly publication process.

Responsibilities of Authors

Authors submitting manuscripts to ICEFCI are responsible for ensuring that their work complies with the following requirements:

2.1. Originality and Authorship

  • Manuscripts must be original and must not have been previously published in substantially the same form.
  • Manuscripts must not be simultaneously submitted to another conference, journal, or publication outlet.
  • All individuals listed as authors must have made meaningful scholarly contributions to the research.
  • All authors must approve the final manuscript and agree to its submission to ICEFCI.
  • Gift authorship, guest authorship, and ghost authorship are not permitted.

2.2. Accuracy and Research Reporting

  • Authors must report research methods, data, analyses, and findings accurately.
  • Fabrication, falsification, manipulation, or selective reporting of research data is prohibited.
  • Authors must provide appropriate citations and acknowledgements for ideas, materials, and findings obtained from other sources.
  • Any significant errors identified after submission or publication must be reported promptly to the editorial team.

2.3. Acknowledgements and Funding

  • Authors must acknowledge individuals and institutions that have provided substantial assistance but do not qualify for authorship.
  • All financial support, grants, and research funding must be disclosed.

2.4. Responsibility for Submission

Authors must ensure that the manuscript complies with the ICEFCI Author Guidelines, publication ethics policy, and applicable legal and institutional requirements.

Responsibilities of Editors

The ICEFCI editorial team is responsible for ensuring a fair, transparent, and academically rigorous publication process.

3.1. Editorial Independence

  • Editorial decisions must be based on the academic quality, originality, relevance, and scholarly contribution of submitted manuscripts.
  • Decisions must not be influenced by the authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, religion, personal relationships, or academic status.
  • Acceptance of conference registration or payment must not determine the editorial outcome of a manuscript.

3.2. Fair Editorial Decisions

  • Editors must ensure that eligible manuscripts undergo an appropriate peer-review process.
  • Editors must evaluate reviewers' recommendations objectively.
  • Editors must communicate editorial decisions and revision requirements clearly to authors.
  • Editors may reject manuscripts that fail to meet ethical, academic, or technical requirements.

3.3. Conflict of Interest

Editors must declare any potential conflicts of interest and withdraw from handling manuscripts where their impartiality may reasonably be questioned. An independent editor should be assigned in such cases.

3.4. Handling Ethical Concerns

Editors must investigate credible allegations of research misconduct, plagiarism, inappropriate authorship, data manipulation, or other ethical violations in accordance with established publication ethics procedures.

Responsibilities of Reviewers

Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the quality and integrity of ICEFCI proceedings.

4.1. Objectivity and Professional Conduct

  • Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively, fairly, and constructively.
  • Reviews must focus on scholarly quality, methodological soundness, originality, relevance, and clarity.
  • Personal criticism, discriminatory comments, and unsupported judgments are not acceptable.

4.2. Confidentiality

  • Manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents.
  • Reviewers must not share, distribute, or discuss manuscripts with unauthorized individuals.
  • Unpublished research information must not be used for personal or professional advantage.

4.3. Acknowledgement of Sources

Reviewers should identify relevant publications that have not been cited by the authors and notify editors of potential plagiarism, duplicate publication, or significant similarities with other works.

4.4. Timeliness

Reviewers should complete evaluations within the assigned deadline. If unable to provide a review, they should promptly inform the editorial team.

4.5. Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must decline assignments where personal, professional, institutional, financial, or collaborative relationships may compromise their impartiality.

Research Integrity and Data Transparency

ICEFCI expects all research to be conducted and reported in accordance with accepted standards of academic integrity.

  • Research data must be collected, analyzed, and reported honestly.
  • Authors must not fabricate, falsify, or manipulate research data, images, statistical outputs, or other research evidence.
  • Research methods and analytical procedures must be described transparently.
  • Authors must not selectively omit findings in ways that misrepresent the research outcomes.
  • Where appropriate and legally permissible, authors should preserve research data and supporting documentation for verification.
  • Authors must ensure that data obtained from third parties are used in accordance with applicable permissions and data protection requirements.
Research transparency: ICEFCI encourages responsible data sharing and reproducible research practices while respecting confidentiality, privacy, intellectual property, and institutional restrictions.

Plagiarism, Similarity, and Duplicate Publication

ICEFCI does not tolerate plagiarism or any form of inappropriate appropriation of intellectual work.

6.1. Forms of Plagiarism

  • Direct plagiarism: copying text or ideas without proper acknowledgement.
  • Paraphrasing plagiarism: presenting another person's ideas or arguments without appropriate citation.
  • Self-plagiarism: reusing previously published material without appropriate disclosure or acknowledgement.
  • Data plagiarism: using research data, tables, figures, or other materials without proper attribution or authorization.
  • Improper attribution: failing to acknowledge the original contributors of scholarly work.

6.2. Similarity Screening

All submitted manuscripts may be subjected to similarity screening using appropriate plagiarism detection software.

ICEFCI may use a similarity threshold of 20% as an initial screening benchmark. However, similarity scores will not be used as the sole basis for determining plagiarism. Editors will examine the nature, context, and sources of textual overlap.

6.3. Duplicate Submission and Publication

  • Submitting substantially identical manuscripts to multiple publication outlets simultaneously is prohibited.
  • Authors must disclose any previous dissemination of related work, including preprints, working papers, or conference abstracts, where relevant.
  • Substantial overlap with previously published material must be appropriately justified and disclosed.
Manuscripts found to contain plagiarism, duplicate publication, or serious intellectual property violations may be rejected or withdrawn from the publication process.

Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Tools

ICEFCI recognizes the growing role of artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies in academic research and scholarly communication. Their use must remain transparent, responsible, and consistent with academic integrity.

7.1. Permitted Uses

Authors may use AI-assisted tools for appropriate purposes, including language editing, grammar checking, translation assistance, literature organization, and research support, provided that such use does not compromise research integrity.

7.2. Disclosure Requirements

  • Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI tools in preparing the manuscript.
  • The disclosure should identify the tool and explain its purpose and scope of use.
  • Authors should include the disclosure in an appropriate section, such as Acknowledgements or an AI Use Declaration.
  • Routine spelling, grammar, and reference formatting assistance does not ordinarily require a separate declaration unless the applicable submission instructions specify otherwise.

7.3. Prohibited Practices

  • Submitting AI-generated content as original human research without appropriate verification and disclosure.
  • Generating or manipulating research data, references, citations, or evidence deceptively.
  • Using AI tools to fabricate research results or scholarly sources.
  • Uploading confidential manuscripts or unpublished research materials to external AI platforms without authorization.
  • Listing AI systems or tools as authors or co-authors.

7.4. Author Accountability

Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, validity, and integrity of all submitted content, including material produced or assisted by AI tools.

AI Disclosure Example:

"The authors used [name of AI tool] for [specific purpose]. All AI-assisted content was reviewed, verified, and revised by the authors, who take full responsibility for the final manuscript."

Conflict of Interest

A conflict of interest occurs when personal, professional, institutional, financial, or other relationships could reasonably be perceived as influencing scholarly judgment or editorial decisions.

Authors, editors, and reviewers must disclose any relevant conflicts of interest, including:

  • Financial relationships, sponsorships, or research funding.
  • Employment, consultancy, or institutional affiliations.
  • Personal or family relationships.
  • Academic collaborations or professional competition.
  • Any other relationships that could compromise objectivity.

Where no conflict exists, authors may include the following statement:

"The authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this manuscript."

Disclosure of a conflict of interest does not automatically imply misconduct or disqualify a manuscript from consideration. Appropriate measures will be taken to ensure an impartial evaluation.

Confidentiality and Information Security

All manuscripts and related editorial communications must be handled confidentially throughout the submission, review, and publication processes.

  • Editors must protect the identities and personal information of authors and reviewers in accordance with the double-blind review policy.
  • Reviewers must not disclose manuscript contents or review reports to unauthorized parties.
  • Unpublished findings must not be used without permission from the original authors.
  • Personal information submitted through the conference system must be used only for legitimate editorial, academic, and administrative purposes.
  • Confidential research data must be protected against unauthorized access or disclosure.

Research Misconduct and Ethical Violations

Research misconduct includes, but is not limited to:

  • Plagiarism and inappropriate appropriation of intellectual work.
  • Fabrication or falsification of research data.
  • Manipulation of images, statistical outputs, or research evidence.
  • Improper authorship attribution.
  • Duplicate or redundant publication.
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
  • Misuse of confidential information.
  • Manipulation of the peer-review process.
  • Misrepresentation of research ethics approval or participant consent.

10.1. Investigation Procedure

When an allegation of misconduct is received, the ICEFCI editorial team will:

  1. Conduct an initial assessment of the allegation and available evidence.
  2. Request clarification or a formal response from the relevant parties where appropriate.
  3. Review supporting documents and consult independent experts when necessary.
  4. Maintain confidentiality and provide a fair opportunity for the parties concerned to respond.
  5. Determine appropriate action based on the evidence and severity of the violation.

10.2. Possible Sanctions

  • Request for correction or clarification.
  • Rejection of the submitted manuscript.
  • Withdrawal of an accepted manuscript.
  • Retraction or correction of published proceedings content where justified.
  • Notification to the relevant institution or research integrity authority when appropriate and legally permissible.
  • Restriction from future submissions to ICEFCI in cases of serious or repeated misconduct.

Corrections, Retractions, and Withdrawal

ICEFCI is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of published conference proceedings.

11.1. Corrections

Corrections may be issued when published papers contain errors that affect the accuracy, clarity, or interpretation of the research but do not invalidate the overall findings.

11.2. Retractions

A published paper may be retracted when substantial evidence indicates serious research misconduct, unreliable findings, plagiarism, unauthorized publication, or other significant ethical violations.

11.3. Withdrawal Before Publication

Authors requesting withdrawal before publication must provide a written explanation to the editorial team. Withdrawal requests will be evaluated to prevent duplicate submission, publication misconduct, and disruption of the editorial process.

11.4. Editorial Action

Decisions regarding corrections, withdrawals, and retractions will be made by the editorial team based on documented evidence, fairness, and established publication ethics principles.

Appeals and Ethical Complaints

ICEFCI provides a mechanism for authors, reviewers, and other relevant parties to raise concerns regarding editorial decisions, peer-review procedures, or alleged ethical violations.

12.1. Appeals Against Editorial Decisions

  • Authors may submit a written appeal explaining the reasons for disagreement with an editorial decision.
  • Appeals must provide substantive academic or procedural grounds supported by relevant evidence.
  • The editorial team may request an independent assessment where necessary.
  • The appeal will be evaluated by an editor who is not directly involved in the original decision, where practicable.
  • The final decision following an appeal will be communicated to the relevant authors.

12.2. Submission of Ethical Complaints

Allegations concerning plagiarism, research misconduct, reviewer misconduct, conflicts of interest, or breaches of confidentiality may be submitted to the ICEFCI editorial team.

12.3. Fair and Confidential Handling

All complaints and appeals will be handled objectively and confidentially. ICEFCI will not tolerate retaliation against individuals who raise legitimate ethical concerns in good faith.

Human Research Ethics and Participant Protection

Research involving human participants, personal information, or sensitive data must comply with applicable ethical standards, institutional requirements, and relevant laws and regulations.

  • Authors must obtain informed consent from participants where required.
  • Research involving vulnerable populations must receive appropriate ethical consideration and safeguards.
  • Personal identities and confidential participant information must be protected.
  • Authors must obtain approval from a recognized research ethics committee or institutional review board where required.
  • Ethics approval details should be provided in the manuscript when applicable.
  • Any exemptions from formal ethical approval must be consistent with applicable institutional and regulatory requirements.
Participant Protection: Authors are responsible for ensuring that research procedures respect participant dignity, privacy, autonomy, and welfare.

Copyright, Licensing, and Publication Rights

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts do not infringe third-party copyright, intellectual property rights, or other applicable legal protections.

  • Authors must obtain permission to reproduce copyrighted figures, photographs, tables, or other materials where required.
  • All third-party materials must be appropriately acknowledged.
  • Authors must confirm that they have the authority to submit the manuscript for publication.
  • Copyright ownership, publication rights, and licensing arrangements must follow the official ICEFCI proceedings policy.
  • Authors must comply with the applicable licensing terms presented during the publication process.

Publication of a manuscript in ICEFCI proceedings does not automatically transfer copyright unless expressly stated in the applicable publication agreement.

Ethical Commitment

By submitting a manuscript to ICEFCI, authors acknowledge their responsibility to comply with this Publication Ethics Policy and all applicable editorial requirements.

The ICEFCI editorial team reserves the right to take appropriate action when ethical violations are identified, in accordance with the seriousness of the issue, the available evidence, and recognized scholarly publication standards.

This policy applies to all parties involved in the preparation, evaluation, and publication of ICEFCI conference proceedings.

↑ BACK TO TOP